By CCN: 2020 presidential hopeful Bernie Sanders and his democratic-socialist protégé Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez are trying to introduce a bill that even AOC describes as “radical.”
Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez & Bernie Sanders Take Aim at Credit Card Interest Rates
The bill would cap all credit card interest rates at 15 percent. Right now, the average banking institution is charging an interest rate of roughly 17 percent on the cards it issues, though interest rates, according to AOC, allegedly balloon high as “30 or 40 percent” in some cases.
New policy proposal dropping tomorrow with a special Senate co-lead 😎
It’s radical, which I always love, and we’re keeping more coins in your pocket, which I also love.
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) May 9, 2019
In a Facebook livestream, the pair referred to the situation as “economic brutality,” citing people that make “millions and millions of dollars a year” (hey, that sounds like Sanders, per his 2016 and 2017 tax returns), and “banks that make billions of dollars a year in profit.”
Similar laws that capped interest rates were in place in the U.S. up until 1978, when the Supreme Court ruled that individual states could enforce their own laws regarding credit cards and their respective interest rates.
Credit Card Rate Cap Will Strangle Free Market
There are two big things wrong with the plan – three if you count the fact that neither AOC nor Sanders has explained how they seek to enforce such a law.
The first is that capping interest rates will strangle competition in our financial markets. Banks compete by setting different interest rates on items like credit cards, home loans, and business loans.
Roughly 183 million Americans own and utilize credit cards to pay for goods and services. By setting different standards regarding interest rates, banks have more room to use differentiated interest rates to attract customers and potentially earn their business, beating out their competitors.
By having a set maximum rate on all cards, consumers have fewer choices regarding what credit cards they will take. Competition is destroyed, and banks would likely suffer financial losses down the line, shaking up the U.S. economy.
Banning High Interest Rates Will HURT Poor Americans
The second problem – and the one that is far more insidious – is that capping interest rates could potentially prevent low-income individuals or people with poor credit from purchasing what they need to survive.
There is no reason a person should pay more than 15% interest in the United States.
It’s common sense – in fact, we had these Usury laws until the 70s.
(Max interest rates are record-high for ppl with excellent credit, too.)
It’s a debt trap for working people + it has to end. https://t.co/tYf4J892KQ
— Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez (@AOC) May 9, 2019
Higher interest rates protect banks and financial institutions when a customer’s payment history is either weak or tarnished.
At the same time, higher interest rates allow these banks to underwrite credit cards, mortgages, and other loans to risky individuals. By agreeing to a higher interest rate, these customers obtain access to the money they desperately need while giving banks enough incentive to run the risk that they will default on their credit card payments.
Bernie Sanders and AOC Are Hurting the Poor, Not Helping Them
By capping interest rates, banks will no longer have the same protection they once did against faulty or poor credit individuals, which could make them less likely to lend money or offer financial resources to people with less-than-stellar payment histories.
Consumer Bankers Association president and CEO Richard Hunt claims:
“Arbitrary, one-size-fits-all caps would make all loans ranging from home mortgages to auto loans to college loans harder for Americans with lower credit scores or non-traditional sources of income to receive.”
Jeff Sigmund, a spokesperson for the American Bankers Association, offered similar commentary. He warned that America is currently enjoying a “highly competitive and vibrant” credit market. He says that by implementing interest caps and limiting card choices for consumers, credit will become more restricted to “those who need it the most.” He also comments that they would be driven to “less regulated, more costly alternatives.”
Sanders and AOC claim they’re working against companies that “prey on the poor.” In reality, they’re the ones virtue-signaling their constituents back into the poor house.
Disclaimer: The views expressed in the article are solely those of the author and do not represent those of, nor should they be attributed to, CCN.