- MedMen terminated its $682 million merger with PharmaCann on Tuesday, in a move one analyst called a “surprise.”
- The merger’s cancellation points to a challenging dealmaking environment in the cannabis industry as the sector has declined close to 50% in the past few months.
- Business Insider spoke with lawyers, bankers, and analysts who work with cannabis companies about what this means for the industry.
- Click here for more BI Prime stories and subscribe to our weekly cannabis newsletter, Cultivated.
It has been a tough week for publicly traded cannabis companies, capping off a difficult few months for the sector.
In a surprise move on Tuesday, MedMen said it was pulling out of its proposed all-stock merger with PharmaCann. The merger, which was first announced in October last year, would have created one of the largest US cannabis companies and was valued at $682 million when it was announced.
Slumping share prices and consistent headwinds in the cannabis industry — namely, fear over illnesses caused by THC vapes and the slowing progress of marijuana legalization in the US — have made for a challenging dealmaking environment, according to bankers, analysts, and lawyers working with cannabis companies that Business Insider spoke with. In the past six months, the Horizons Marijuana Life Sciences Index ETF, a fund that tracks cannabis stocks in the US and Canada, has slipped close to 50%.
“The initial wave of investors that went after this market has been tapped out or exhausted,” Marc Hauser, the vice chair of the law firm Reed Smith’s cannabis team told Business Insider in an interview. “Companies are having a much harder time raising capital than just 12 months ago.”
For his part, MedMen CEO Adam Bierman cited the challenging capital-markets environment for cannabis companies and the need to change up strategies as the reasons for the deal’s termination. The company also pushed out its chief financial officer, Michael Kramer, and replaced him with Zeeshan Hyder.
It’s MedMen’s third chief financial officer inside a year. Business Insider reported on the departure of MedMen’s chief marketing officer, David Dancer, in September.
Vivien Azer, an analyst at the investment bank Cowen, called the deal’s failure a “surprise” after it cleared a Department of Justice antitrust review a month ago and MedMen put out an “optimistic” statement about the deal’s prospects.
MedMen isn’t the only cannabis company facing troubling news this week. Hexo Corp. pulled its 2020 forecast on Thursday, citing a challenging operating environment in Canada, causing its shares to free-fall. And on Wednesday, Aleafia terminated a supply agreement with Aphria after it said the latter company didn’t meet obligations, causing shares in both companies to tumble.
‘The environment is really challenging’
Murray Huneke, a managing director at the San Francisco-based boutique investment bank North Point Advisors, told Business Insider that there were some factors “specific” to MedMen that led to its failure to close the PharmaCann deal — notably, constant executive turnover and lower share prices than its competitors. But it’s still a tough time to be a cannabis company.
“The environment is really challenging from a capital-markets perspective,” Huneke said. “Market caps for cannabis companies have been cut in half since their highs.”
Huneke said cannabis companies were going to think back to “frothier” times — like earlier this year — and hoard cash to weather the storm, especially as legalization in the US has been progressing slower than expected.
“It’s better to be a survivor in the long run,” Huneke said.
Most banks won’t lend to the cannabis industry because THC is federally illegal in the US. That’s forced companies to use their stock as currency to fuel acquisitions. And when share prices fall, it makes those deals harder to close.
For a seller like PharmaCann, getting MedMen’s stock in return for control of the company might have seemed like a great bet last year. Now that MedMen’s share price has plummeted, it no longer seems like such a good idea — and this pattern is replicated all over the cannabis industry, Jesse Pytlak, a cannabis analyst at the investment bank Cormark Securities, said.
“There’s a risk to all of these deals,” Pytlak said. “It’s more unique with MedMen as the stock price has performed quite poorly relative to others.”
People aren’t paying to ‘dot up a map’ anymore
In the last quarter of 2018, and through the first few months of this year, US cannabis companies like Harvest Health and Recreation and Curaleaf, among others — known in industry parlance as multistate operators (MSOs) — went on a follow-the-leader dealmaking tear, announcing near-billion-dollar acquisitions one after another to build up scale and fill out the map with operating licenses in states where marijuana is legal.
“Putting together deals because everyone else is doing it — I don’t think it’s the same environment at all,” Huneke said.
Six months to a year later, a lot of these deals still haven’t closed, gummed up by Department of Justice antitrust investigations, slumping share prices, and “incremental” rather than “revolutionary” marijuana legalization in the US, Scott Hammon, a partner at the accounting and advisory firm MGO, said. That and the deals have gotten a lot larger and more complex.
“Public companies have mostly disappointed investors’ expectations,” Hammon said. “Many parties agree there was a bit of a bubble mentality. Valuations didn’t forecast true operating results, and the significant reductions in valuations make it much harder to close all-stock deals.”
To Huneke, the days when cannabis companies would pay to “dot up a map” are over. “The currency is worth much less, and cash is harder to find,” Huneke said. “Efficiency and execution are hard. People are saying, ‘When are we going to see real cash flow and real scale? Who’s winning specific markets.'”